DEDMA BLUES | Human Rights Watch dismayed at PH spurning of Review recommendations

September 22, 2017 - 7:54 PM
Human Rights Watch
Human Rights Watch

The international non-governmental organization Human Rights Watch on Friday expressed dismay that the Philippines rejected UPR recommendations “that would make a practical difference in ending extrajudicial killings perpetrated in the name of its murderous ‘war on drugs’.”

UPR refers to the United Nations Human Rights Council’s Universal Periodic Review of the Philippines.

The Universal Periodic Review involves a review of the human rights records of all UN Member States under the auspices of the Human Rights Council. It provides the opportunity for each State to declare what actions they have taken to improve the human rights situations in their countries and to fulfil their human rights obligations.

The Philippines received 257 recommendations. It “supported” just 103 of those recommendations and “noted” the other 154.

On September 22, HRW issued a statement calling on the United Nations human rights body to “ensure accountability for unlawful killings.”

The statement comes during the period of the Human Rights Council’s Thirty-sixth session [11-29 September 2017], in which the adoption of the outcome of the Philippines UPR is part of the agenda.

HRW said: “We are dismayed that the Philippines rejected all UPR recommendations that would make a practical difference in ending extrajudicial killings perpetrated in the name of its murderous ‘war on drugs’.”

According to HRW, the Philippines “rejected Peru’s recommendation to cooperate with special procedures by extending a standing invitation, and recommendations by Ghana, Hungary and others to allow access to the Special Rapporteur on extrajudicial executions, without conditions that might compromise her impartiality.

“We remind Philippines of its obligation as a member to cooperate with the Council and its mechanisms.

“We are deeply concerned that rather than investigating compelling evidence of culpability of police and their agents in many of those killings, Duterte has launched a campaign of vilification and harassment against individuals and institutions pursuing accountability for those abuses, Senator Leila de Lima, who faces politically motivated drug charges designed to silence her, the official Commission on Human Rights, as well as the Special Rapporteur on extrajudicial executions.

“In its UPR responses, the Philippines even refused to accept recommendations to protect journalists and human rights defenders, or reject incitement to violence.

“Instead of calling for respect for international standards or due process, President Duterte has said of drug suspects: ‘My order is to shoot to kill you. I don’t care about human rights, you better believe me.’ And ‘I will kill you, I will kill you. Forget about the laws of men, forget about the laws of international law, whatever.’”

Human Rights Watch asked: “Does the delegation deny President Duterte made these remarks? Does it believe that any killing without due process is justified if perpetrated in the name of the “war on drugs?”

The UN High Commissioner had noted in his update to this session: “I continue to be gravely concerned by the President’s open support for a shoot-to-kill policy regarding suspects, as well as by the apparent absence of credible investigations into reports of thousands of extrajudicial killings, and the failure to prosecute any perpetrator.”

HRW said that, if the Philippines will not face up to its international responsibilities and membership obligations, “the Human Rights Council should step in, and do all that it can to end the violence, support a United Nations-supervised investigations into the deaths, and demand accountability for all unlawful killings.”